pes-test (Vol. 1)

pure engine strength test (Vol. 1) ...

... without books, tablebases and without learning !

Level       :  see below
CPU         :  Intel i5 @ 3.1GHz
Core(s)     :  1
ponder      :  on
all engines :  x64
HTs         :  see below
TBs         :  none
SBs         :  none
Learning    :  off
 
GUI         :  Shredder Classic
 
from the starting position with colour change = 2 games per match

Level 8'+2" / 128MB HTs

Engine          |  Kom  |  Sto  |  Hou  |  Gul  |  Equ  |  Ryb  |  Cri  | Total |  +  =  -  | Rank |
====================================================================================================
Komodo 8.0      | xxxxx | 1w ½b | ½w 1b | ½w ½b | 0w ½b | 1w ½b | 1w 1b |  8.0  |  5  6  1  |   1  |
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Stockfish 5.0   | ½w 0b | xxxxx | ½w ½b | 1w ½b | 1w 1b | 1w ½b | 1w ½b |  8.0  |  5  6  1  |   2  |
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Houdini 4.0     | 0w ½b | ½w ½b | xxxxx | 0w ½b | 1w ½b | 1w 1b | 1w 1b |  7.5  |  5  5  2  |   3  |
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Gull 3.0        | ½w ½b | ½w 0b | ½w 1b | xxxxx | 1w ½b | ½w 0b | 1w ½b |  6.5  |  3  7  2  |   4  |
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Equinox 3.30    | ½w 1b | 0w 0b | ½w 0b | ½w 0b | xxxxx | ½w 1b | 1w 0b |  5.0  |  3  4  5  |   5  |
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Rybka 4.0       | ½w 0b | ½w 0b | 0w 0b | 1w ½b | 0w ½b | xxxxx | 1w ½b |  4.5  |  2  5  5  |   6  |
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Critter 1.6     | 0w 0b | ½w 0b | 0w 0b | ½w 0b | 1w 0b | ½w 0b | xxxxx |  2.5  |  1  3  8  |   7  |
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

White total      25.0 out of 42 (59.5%) 
Black total      17.0 out of 42 (40.5%)
Draws            18   out of 42 (42.8%)

Ø moves per game = 85

Komodo     with White   4.0 out of 6
Komodo     with Black   4.0 out of 6

Stockfish  with White   5.0 out of 6
Stockfish  with Black   3.0 out of 6

Houdini    with White   3.5 out of 6
Houdini    with Black   4.0 out of 6

Gull       with White   4.0 out of 6
Gull       with Black   2.5 out of 6

Equinox    with White   3.0 out of 6
Equinox    with Black   2.0 out of 6

Rybka      with White   3.0 out of 6
Rybka      with Black   1.5 out of 6

Critter    with White   2.5 out of 6
Critter    with Black   0.0 out of 6

Level 17'+3" / 512MB HTs

Engine          |  Kom  |  Sto  |  Hou  |  Gul  |  Equ  |  Ryb  |  Cri  | Total |  +  =  -  | Rank |
====================================================================================================
Komodo 8.0      | xxxxx | ½w 1b | 1w ½b | 1w ½b | 1w 1b | 1w 1b | 1w 1b | 10.5  |  9  3  0  |   1  |
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Stockfish 5.0   | 0w ½b | xxxxx | ½w 1b | 0w ½b | ½w ½b | 1w 1b | 1w ½b |  7.0  |  4  6  2  |   2  |
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Houdini 4.0     | ½w 0b | 0w ½b | xxxxx | ½w 0b | 0w ½b | ½w ½b | 1w 1b |  5.0  |  2  6  4  |   5  |
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Gull 3.0        | ½w 0b | ½w 1b | 1w ½b | xxxxx | 0w ½b | ½w 1b | 0w 1b |  6.5  |  4  5  3  |   4  |
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Equinox 3.30    | 0w 0b | ½w ½b | ½w 1b | ½w 1b | xxxxx | ½w ½b | 1w ½b |  6.5  |  3  7  2  |   3  |
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Rybka 4.0       | 0w 0b | 0w 0b | ½w ½b | 0w ½b | ½w ½b | xxxxx | ½w ½b |  3.5  |  0  7  5  |   6  |
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Critter 1.6     | 0w 0b | ½w 0b | 0w 0b | 0w 1b | ½w 0b | ½w ½b | xxxxx |  3.0  |  1  4  7  |   7  |
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

White total      19.5 out of 42 (46.4%) 
Black total      22.5 out of 42 (53.6%)
Draws            19   out of 42 (45.2%)

Ø moves per game = 91

Komodo     with White   5.5 out of 6
Komodo     with Black   5.0 out of 6

Stockfish  with White   3.0 out of 6
Stockfish  with Black   4.0 out of 6

Houdini    with White   2.5 out of 6
Houdini    with Black   2.5 out of 6

Gull       with White   2.5 out of 6
Gull       with Black   4.0 out of 6

Equinox    with White   3.0 out of 6
Equinox    with Black   3.5 out of 6

Rybka      with White   1.5 out of 6
Rybka      with Black   2.0 out of 6

Critter    with White   1.5 out of 6
Critter    with Black   1.5 out of 6

Best wishes,
G.S.

.. and now with Stockfish DEV (07/01/2015)

Level 8'+2" / 128MB HTs

Engine          |  Kom  |  Sto  |  Hou  |  Gul  |  Equ  |  Ryb  |  Cri  | Total |  +  =  -  | Rank |
====================================================================================================
Komodo 8.0      | xxxxx | 0w ½b | ½w 1b | ½w ½b | 0w ½b | 1w ½b | 1w 1b |  7.0  |  4  6  2  |   2  |
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Stockfish DEV   | ½w 1b | xxxxx | ½w 1b | 1w 1b | 1w ½b | ½w ½b | ½w 1b |  9.0  |  6  6  0  |   1  |
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Houdini 4.0     | 0w ½b | 0w ½b | xxxxx | 0w ½b | 1w ½b | 1w 1b | 1w 1b |  7.0  |  5  4  3  |   3  |
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Gull 3.0        | ½w ½b | 0w 0b | ½w 1b | xxxxx | 1w ½b | ½w 0b | 1w ½b |  6.0  |  3  6  3  |   4  |
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Equinox 3.30    | ½w 1b | ½w 0b | ½w 0b | ½w 0b | xxxxx | ½w 1b | 1w 0b |  5.5  |  3  5  4  |   5  |
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Rybka 4.0       | ½w 0b | ½w ½b | 0w 0b | 1w ½b | 0w ½b | xxxxx | 1w ½b |  5.0  |  2  6  4  |   6  |
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Critter 1.6     | 0w 0b | 0w ½b | 0w 0b | ½w 0b | 1w 0b | ½w 0b | xxxxx |  2.5  |  1  3  8  |   7  |
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

White total      22.0 out of 42 (52.3%) 
Black total      20.0 out of 42 (47.6%)
Draws            18   out of 42 (42.8%)

Ø moves per game = 84

Komodo     with White   3.0 out of 6
Komodo     with Black   4.0 out of 6

Stockfish  with White   4.0 out of 6
Stockfish  with Black   5.0 out of 6

Houdini    with White   3.0 out of 6
Houdini    with Black   4.0 out of 6

Gull       with White   3.5 out of 6
Gull       with Black   2.5 out of 6

Equinox    with White   3.5 out of 6
Equinox    with Black   2.0 out of 6

Rybka      with White   3.0 out of 6
Rybka      with Black   2.0 out of 6

Critter    with White   2.0 out of 6
Critter    with Black   0.5 out of 6

Level 17'+3" / 512MB HTs

Engine          |  Kom  |  Sto  |  Hou  |  Gul  |  Equ  |  Ryb  |  Cri  | Total |  +  =  -  | Rank |
====================================================================================================
Komodo 8.0      | xxxxx | 0w 1b | 1w ½b | 1w ½b | 1w 1b | 1w 1b | 1w 1b | 10.0  |  9  2  1  |   1  |
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Stockfish DEV   | 0w 1b | xxxxx | 1w ½b | 1w ½b | 1w ½b | 1w ½b | 1w 1b |  9.0  |  7  4  1  |   2  |
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Houdini 4.0     | ½w 0b | ½w 0b | xxxxx | ½w 0b | 0w ½b | ½w ½b | 1w 1b |  5.0  |  2  6  4  |   5  |
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Gull 3.0        | ½w 0b | ½w 0b | 1w ½b | xxxxx | 0w ½b | ½w 1b | 0w 1b |  5.5  |  3  5  4  |   4  |
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Equinox 3.30    | 0w 0b | ½w 0b | ½w 1b | ½w 1b | xxxxx | ½w ½b | 1w ½b |  6.0  |  3  6  3  |   3  |
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Rybka 4.0       | 0w 0b | ½w 0b | ½w ½b | 0w ½b | ½w ½b | xxxxx | ½w ½b |  4.0  |  0  8  4  |   6  |
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Critter 1.6     | 0w 0b | 0w 0b | 0w 0b | 0w 1b | ½w 0b | ½w ½b | xxxxx |  2.5  |  1  3  8  |   7  |
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

White total      21.5 out of 42 (51.2%) 
Black total      20.5 out of 42 (48.8%)
Draws            17   out of 42 (40.4%)

Ø moves per game = 91

Komodo     with White   5.0 out of 6
Komodo     with Black   5.0 out of 6

Stockfish  with White   5.0 out of 6
Stockfish  with Black   4.0 out of 6

Houdini    with White   3.0 out of 6
Houdini    with Black   2.0 out of 6

Gull       with White   2.5 out of 6
Gull       with Black   3.0 out of 6

Equinox    with White   3.0 out of 6
Equinox    with Black   3.0 out of 6

Rybka      with White   2.0 out of 6
Rybka      with Black   2.0 out of 6

Critter    with White   1.0 out of 6
Critter    with Black   1.5 out of 6

Best wishes,
G.S.